Art of Message

Share this post

Karl Marx on Hourly Billing

www.artofmessage.xyz

Karl Marx on Hourly Billing

Rowan Price-Gauger
Jun 23, 2020
Share this post

Karl Marx on Hourly Billing

www.artofmessage.xyz

Neil Gaiman is one of those writers who win all the awards - Hugo, Nebula, Newbury, and more. So he's written a lot of books. But if you're like me and his name rings a bell, it's because he wrote one of the first massively popular graphic novels, a series called The Sandman. Gaiman offers us a framework for how to benefit from criticism:

Remember: when someone tells you something's wrong or doesn't work for them, they are almost always right.

When they tell you exactly what they think is wrong - and how to fix - they are almost always wrong.

This truth is why a good business consultant will quickly identify problems – yet be slow to offer unilateral solutions. It's always why client-led solutions work best.

Neil Gaiman isn't the writer I quoted yesterday, but his framework applies to the book I quoted: The Communist Manifesto, by Marx and Engels.

(Congratulations if you guessed right!!)

Twenty-nine year old Karl Marx understood what was wrong with industrial capitalism: wage-labor tries to turn human beings into machine parts, with repulsive results. He was right about what was wrong.

But his and Frederick Engels' fixes were (with a few notable exceptions) absurd to the point of scandalous (eg. abolishing families). Maybe Marx would have been appalled by the murder-state that was Soviet Russia, but whether he realized it or not, his policies required totalitarianism.

One takeaway here is that any criticism has a diamond-in-the-rough value; you have to chip away the "how to fix" parts but listen for the "this seems wrong parts".

Here's the more specific takeaway that even Karl Marx would agree with: there are many ways to monetize the value of your expertise, but billing by the hour isn't one of them. It just seems wrong to me.

My best,
Rowan

Share this post

Karl Marx on Hourly Billing

www.artofmessage.xyz
Comments
TopNew

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Rowan Price
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing